ESPN are reporting that the Colts are making Jonathan Taylor available. They are seeking a deal similar to the Christian McCaffrey trade. The 49ers spent a second, third, fourth and fifth round pick on McCaffrey.
Tom Pelissero is additionally reporting they’ve already turned down an offer of a second round pick and a later round pick.
Among the teams listed as expressing interest are the Seahawks and this is creating a mixed reaction online.
First and foremost, the Seahawks are in their Championship window right now. This will not last multiple years. Several players are older and an opportunity is very clearly emerging this season to do something only two other teams have done since the turn of the century — repeat as Champions.
Giving away a lot of picks for one player, particularly a 27-year-old running back, will be difficult for some people to accept.
Consider this though. The Seahawks are on the road against the 49ers in the Divisional playoff round in a few weeks time. You can have Jonathan Taylor in the backfield or Emmanuel Wilson. Would you be worrying about draft picks in that situation?
The obvious counter to this is the ability to get Zach Charbonnet and Jadarian Price back and not need to invest in a running back. There’s at least some mystery, however, about Charbonnet’s ability to play and be close to his best coming off an ACL injury. With Price, he is a rookie. He’s fumbled twice and had a stint on IR. He was never the lead back even in college.
With the trade deadline a week-and-a-half away, can you risk the possibility of your running game relying on Wilson as your lead back? Are you better off being aggressive now to potentially find the missing piece to a complete roster? That has to at least be considered, given the Championship opportunity on offer.
Some are saying it would be too rich to use a first round pick on Price and then trade a lot for Jonathan Taylor. It’s worth remembering they spent the #41 pick on Ken Walker and the #52 pick on Charbonnet in back-to-back years. It wouldn’t be that different if they used #32 on Price, then a second rounder plus on Taylor.
I actually think the price tag for Taylor will drop. The Colts apparently initially wanted a first rounder. Now it’s a Christian McCaffrey deal. I recall the Seahawks wanting a first for DK Metcalf before settling on a late second. I suspect a round two pick and perhaps something else in 2028, say a third rounder, might get it done. Patience might be key for all interested parties, which is why the Colts are using the media today to try and pump the market up.
Can the Seahawks afford him? I’d recommend checking out Curtis Allen’s brilliant piece yesterday noting how they can raise cap space to do so. I also wouldn’t worry too much about being able to acquire Taylor and keep Quenton Nelson long term. If you want to do it — you can. And it’s worth noting that they might’ve planned to pay Sam Darnold a large contract next year, something that seems less likely today. They might be able to make a saving there. Plus, an extension for Byron Murphy will be structured in a way that his big money likely won’t hit the books for a while yet (as an extension, he’ll likely play on his fourth and fifth years of his rookie deal, then the big cap hit kicks in).
Jonathan Jones at the Athletic is reporting today that Jarran Reed could be available via trade. That would save $3.2m, to add to Seattle’s $3.9m in effective cap space. Acquiring Taylor this year would cost $5m for the rest of the season. This would be a way to make it work. Losing Reed would be a tough pill to swallow but his PFF grades (I know) are not good across the board and he turns 34 in December. Could they be prepared to give Brandon Pili more snaps, knowing Byron Murphy and Leonard Williams are going to eat a lot of the interior action?
I think Taylor to Seattle is plausible. I think the Seahawks might think they are one top running back away from being complete. Getting Taylor would undoubtedly put them in a place where they could be seen as significant Super Bowl favourites. I suspect they would rather be overstocked than understocked. But they will also have a price in mind and won’t mortgage the future on this.
Much will depend on their confidence in Charbonnet and Price and the truth is we just don’t know where they’re at. Only the team does.
If the Seahawks win another Super Bowl this season, this roster will be the stuff of legend. That has to be a driving thought in any move they make over the next week or so.
I don’t know if this will happen — but I think it could.
