
“Pay the man!”
I can remember a time not that long ago where this was a regular battle cry among Seahawks fans.
The Earl Thomas contract situation was perhaps the best example. There was practically a campaign online pressuring the Seahawks to give him a new deal. Some people were apoplectic at the idea they’d let him walk.
When he held out, fans began to pick sides.
Those of us who thought the team were right to manage their cap situation were often caught in the firing line. I’ve told the story a few times that David Mulugheta, Thomas’ agent at the time, called me to complain about an article I’d written criticising his decision to hold out.
In the end the Seahawks were proven right not to act. Just as they also were right not to rush to pay Geno Smith, despite similar calls online to make him a newly minted quarterback worthy of the status of franchise signal-caller.
The point I’m making is that for whatever reason, some people end up rooting for players to be paid the absolute most — even if it can negatively impact the team they play for. It’s as if they are personally invested in the player’s earning potential and will celebrate when they pull off what is considered a winning negotiation.
I’ve never understood this.
My main priority is for the Seahawks to win. One of the ways for the Seahawks to win is to have as much available cap space as possible to build the best team.
Instead of ‘Pay the man!’ I will always root for ‘I hope the Seahawks get the best possible deal!’ instead. Nothing about that is cold or anti-player. I want every single thing that happens involving this team to go towards improving the chances of winning on a Sunday.
In some cases, such as the Jaxon Smith-Njigba extension, it’s impossible not to commit to a record-breaking deal. When it happened I had no real emotion other than ‘I’m glad this was sorted effectively and with no drama’. The deal was done and we all move on. I was neither personally excited for JSN (he’s not lending me a tenner any time soon) nor was I disappointed that the financial commitment was eye-watering.
Keeping great players on massive contracts is part of being a winner. You need to keep your top players and when they produce like JSN has, it’s not a problem at all when they get paid top dollar.
When we aren’t talking about the best of the best at a particular position though, I’m not going to root for the player in a contract negotiation to get every cent that he can. Any money saved benefits the team.
I also think it’s slightly problematic, in some cases, that players are often advised — and encouraged by fans and media — to approach their careers through the prism of draining every drop out of a contract negotiation.
I’m sure some people will criticise Derick Hall and his representatives for the new contract he has just signed. It’s worth $15.27m in fully guaranteed money — less than the arrangement Boye Mafe has with the Bengals ($19m in full guarantees). Their contract values are significantly different — $40m vs $60m.
There’s very little doubt that Hall could and maybe should’ve got more out of the Seahawks.
For once though, let’s not just focus on money. There’s more to life than money. Especially when you’re already a multi-millionaire.
Hall is now financially secure, he’s where he wants to be, he’s playing a sport with good friends in a city where he is clearly settled, competing for a winning franchise who are currently World Champions.
Life is good.
Now imagine the alternative. He ‘gambles on himself’ and succeeds in 2026. He gets a lot more money as a free agent, preferably with another contender or by re-signing with the Seahawks. That’s the ideal situation.
In order to get to that point though he has to risk staying healthy, he has to perform and he has to wait out the situation knowing that at any time things could go horribly wrong.
Is that truly worth it to be a bit more of a millionaire, maybe, in 12 months?
I think he made the right call in all honestly. I won’t argue his team couldn’t have gotten more. They probably could’ve done. But the concept of taking a good deal now rather than betting on a great deal later isn’t getting the backing it should within the NFL community.
He can now fully commit to mini-camp, training camp, pre-season and the regular season without any fear that one serious injury will cost him a fortune. He can prepare in the exact same way he did last year, fully focused on football and not a contract battle, to try and help his team win another Super Bowl.
I couldn’t live with the crushing anxiety of knowing I’m one divot in the turf away from tearing an ACL and your whole life changing, all for the sake of potentially earning more money in the future. If he got badly hurt in training camp he’d be looking at possible prove-it deals from next year, potentially having to move around the country, playing for lesser teams, always wondering what could’ve been.
Now, all of that stress is gone. He has secured at least $15.27m in full guarantees and knows for the next few years he will be with the Seahawks — hopefully competing for more titles.
I would argue that peace of mind is priceless.
Hall clearly likes playing for this team, with his current team-mates. Why would you want to risk forcing yourself to play somewhere else for more money? Happiness is more important. Getting up every day and loving where you live and work is the life goal to end all life goals. If you make that your reality, and can be paid millions for the privilege, then why jeopardise it?
Sure — he could have a 10-sack season, go into free agency next year and get far more. Then what? End up playing for a bad team with a lot more cap space? Weaken your chances of winning? Play with people you don’t like? Live somewhere you constantly compare to Seattle and wish you were back where you were happy?
When Hall is 50-years-old and reflecting on his career, is he ever going to talk about regretting this contract negotiation? Probably not. Nobody is going to hand you an award as a player for a fantastic contract wrangle where you won the day. There’s no Championship ring engraved with ‘got $12m more in guarantees when I negotiated my second contract’.
You do get a prize, though, for winning a Super Bowl. I would argue earning a little bit less to play for a serious franchise is everything.
If the Seahawks continue to succeed, in 20 years Hall and his former team-mates will be able to get together, share stories and reflect on the great memories they made together. Hopefully that will include more than the one Super Bowl appearance.
That’s what life is about. Hall is never going to consider, “if I’d held out for the Boye Mafe deal I might have an even bigger house now” when he’s retired.
Normalising happiness, security and a chance to succeed over getting as much as you can is something that I think would be a positive change — even if it’s just in the case of the rare exception, like this one, where we just celebrate Hall’s decision rather than critique it.
It’s so important for players to have the freedom to enjoy their careers rather than feel pressure to max out their earning power. I’m sure the league is full of players who are richer yet living with regret.