The problem with C.J. Stroud

I stayed up until 5am to watch a recording of Notre Dame vs Ohio State, purposefully to watch C.J. Stroud.

It was more of the same from last year.

It’s obvious he is going to ‘wow’ a whole bunch of teams at his pro-day because his physical tools are obvious. He can get out of the pocket and throw off-balance and from different angles. The way he contorts his body and delivers from difficult launch points is very mondern-NFL.

He will no doubt do the one thing all QB’s do at pro-day nowadays in shorts and a T-shirt — run one way then throw across his body, against the grain, downfield. That clip will go viral, everyone on twitter will go nuts and some NFL scouts and coaches will be smitten.

However, his accuracy and consistency remains a big issue and I continue to wonder if he isn’t just a great big tease.

Stroud lost Garrett Wilson and Chris Olave to the draft this year — both were top-12 picks. In the early exchanges he also lost likely first rounder Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Without his arsenal of great weapons, there were some struggles early against Notre Dame. He seemed to lose composure and he toiled.

His timing was off, he threw behind and high. There were late throws. Granted there were occasions where receivers could’ve made his life easier too by settling down in zone and simply presenting a target. Yet you couldn’t help but notice the number of passes sailing off target.

At one point he was 11/13 for 82 yards on underneath throws (-10 yards) and 1/7 for 21 yards on +10 yard throws. The easy dump-offs were working but barely anything else was.

He settled down a bit in the second half, lobbing a nice seam-pass for a crucial touchdown — but there were still some misses.

I can’t help but think we’ve seen this before. A toolsy Ohio State QB with everything delivered on a plate. Favourable scheme, loads of weapons, physical tools. A player with talent but he can’t put it all together to be a rounded, competent quarterback.

The way he managed this game was in stark contrast to Florida’s Anthony Richardson. He seemed in complete command of his offense and played the percentages. It was a lot more up-and-down for Stoud.

His short and intermediate game isn’t great and that’s where the accuracy problems show up the most. His awareness on third and medium isn’t great, unlike Richardson who knew to throw beyond the sticks to move the chains. His timing was off, he missed the mark too often and his screen passes would fit perfectly in Seattle in that they’re not very good.

The other side to the story though is Justin Herbert. At Oregon, he also had all the tools but was wildly erratic and underwhelming. He was stuck in a boring offense that required him to check-down and throw bubble-screens and short slants galore. We never got to see Herbert at his best (and I fear Tyler Van Dyke will be similarly restricted under the same coaching staff, now in Miami).

Yet once Herbert arrived in the NFL he took off. Playing in a more progressive offense that really showed off his physical tools — he became one of the stars of the league. He was unleashed. It’s not out of the question Stroud could do the same thing.

That’s the big question for Stroud. Is he another Herbert? After all, Herbert had 15 interceptions last year despite his blossoming stock. It’s not hard to imagine Stroud having some of the same issues but also some of the same positives as Herbert. And who wouldn’t take that? I’m not saying he is Herbert. I’m just trying to offset my concerns with the other side of what needs to be considered with Stroud.

To that extent, he’s in a similar boat to Will Levis — who I also think can be a Herbert type at the next level. I think there’s a bit more magic to Levis and it’s harder to elevate Kentucky than it is to win with Ohio State. He’s also coming from a pro-style offense working with a McVay disciple and now a Shanahan coach.

Both players will be debated for their pro’s and con’s a lot and probably analysed more than the other QB’s eligible for 2023. Bryce Young, eventually, is going to be viewed as a 5-9, 190lbs thrower without the sturdiness of other shorter QB’s (Brees, Wilson, Murray). Van Dyke is a fantastic player and should get more attention. Richardson, after his performance last night — will be the toast of the town this week. If he continues to perform the way he did on Sunday, the sky’s the limit for him.

For Stroud — I think perception is greater than reality at the moment. He will be one of the tougher players to analyse pre-draft. Do you believe in the physical upside enough to imagine he can star in the pro’s? Or is he going to be just too erratic and inconsistent to ever deliver on his potential?

After one week of college football, Florida’s Richardson would lead a draftable quarterback power-ranking. I have watched Levis vs Miami-Ohio and I thought he was terrific, despite the porous offensive line he was playing behind and what appeared to be a miscommunication on an interception. Other than that, he showed off his NFL arm and ability to drive the ball and make difficult pro-level throws look easy.

Ohio State play four home games to start the season. They next face powderpuff outings against Arkansas State and Toledo and then host Wisconsin. They won’t face a truly difficult test until Michigan on November 26th.

Stroud’s biggest showcase until Michigan came in his opening game. His team won — but it wasn’t a convincing performance.

If you missed my notes on Anthony Richardson and a host of other quarterbacks yesterday, click here.

And if you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, why not consider supporting the site via Patreon? (click the tab below)

Become a Patron!


  1. AlaskaHawk

    I’m going to look on the positive side . You’ve identified 2 potential quarterbacks for the Seahawks. We will watch them and others to see how they play.

    I’m also wondering at what round will Alabama’s Young be a good value? Late first based on ability or third round based on small body?

    • Rob Staton

      He will likely be first round. But I don’t think as early as many are suggesting

  2. Vin

    Thank you once again Rob! The fact that you stayed up til 5am to not only rewatch a game, but then also present article after article is beyond amazing (borderline crazy, in a good way). Here’s a question…does Stroud’s skills/style translate potentially well as a future Seahawks QB? And if not, which QB in the current crop does? I’m fascinated when I see examples such as Herbert who, like you said, maybe had the wrong college system, but flourished in the NFL. Or when drafts are re-mocked after the fact and players go higher, assuming they would’ve done exactly the same under another team (Mahomes, etc). I worry that with the current seahawks staff, that even if they draft the right QB (or the one we like based off one of your SDB articles) that they’ll F it up and waste a great talent.

    BTW, bought the digital copy of Maverick, based solely on reviews of my friends and you as well. Great Movie! Don’t regret one bit, watching it again tonight. I now understand the Call Sign: Bob reference. Go Hawks!

    • Rob Staton

      borderline crazy

      My wife agrees

      does Stroud’s skills/style translate potentially well as a future Seahawks QB?

      Possibly. They love physical traits and the ability to drive the ball downfield. I don’t see them being massively put off him by some of the concerns I have — but he might not be their top guy

      BTW, bought the digital copy of Maverick, based solely on reviews of my friends and you as well. Great Movie!

      If you get a chance, check it out at a cinema. Unbelievable experience in IMAX!

      • Dave1401

        Have to admit I shelled out for IMax a few weeks ago solely because of your rave review. Worth it!

        Maybe we need movie Mondays here?

  3. Rob Staton

    Bryce Ford-Wheaton (WR, West Virginia) definitely one to watch BTW

    • Starhawk29

      Agreed. Iirc, he did have one rather egregious drop in the 4th quarter though.

      • Rob Staton

        It went through his hands and was picked off. Everything else about his performance though was lights out

  4. Romeo A57

    Is it fair of me to not trust Ohio State or Alabama QBs potential in the NFL because they play on teams that are over stuffed with NFL talent?

    Tua and Fields don’t look like franchise QBs at this point. Even Lawrence is not terribly impressive, yet and he was considered a possible generational talent.

    In recent years, I can think of Joe B and Cam N as QBs who were on dominate college teams, that could be considered elite NFL QBs. Cam obviously had a short shelf life from trying to run like a fullback.

    • Rob Staton

      It’s a fair question to raise, for sure

      • Palatypus

        About half of the receivers they threw to are a #1 or a #2.

    • Big Mike

      Really hard to judge Lawrence based on last year considering he had a total jok3 for a HC. Having Doug Pedersen as his HC and tutor should do wonders for him.

  5. CaptainJack

    I watched the utah Florida game this afternoon. Honestly, Utah should have won. Two terrible sequences in the red zone cost them. Richardson isn’t extremely impressive to me, that Utah defense is filled with a bunch of sub-sec level players.

    • Rob Staton

      Captain Jack:

      Michael Pennix Jr should be on the watch list after beating Kent State

      Also Captain Jack:

      I am the only person on the planet not impressed by Anthony Richardson on Saturday


  6. Jabroni-DC

    It will be interesting to see which of the “Big Boys” size wise demonstrates the processing speed & accuracy that separate great QBs from rest.

    Tyler Van Dyke
    QB | Miami
    224 lbs

    Anthony Richardson
    QB | Florida
    232 lbs

    Will Levis
    QB | Kentucky
    232 lbs

    CJ Stroud
    QB | Ohio State
    215 lbs

    I don’t know how accurate those measurables are but few people would complain about their height.

  7. Ashish

    Is it fair to say based on current information on QBs for upcoming draft we will have a good chance to select one of our choice. We have two 1 ‘s but other teams too have the same. Exciting time thanks to Russ trade.

  8. KD

    How the mighty have fallen. LSU is an absolute laughingstock of a team right now.

    • Rob Staton

      I’ve always had a little bit of a soft spot for LSU. Very difficult to retain that with Brian Kelly in charge.

      • MarkinSeattle

        LSU looked like a typical Brian Kelly coached team. I expect him to get slaughtered by three or more TD’s against the top 10 teams on their schedule and lose more than 2/3 of games against ranked opponents.

        • Rob Staton

          LSU seemingly forgot about the all beatings Kelly suffered in the key playoff games against proper teams…

  9. Ukhawk

    Watched Levis and, boy, that line looks terrible

    I’d like to see more moition and quicker cadence from he and the offense. He seemed a bit flatfooted and didn’t really speed up his release much.

    He made some great decisions and throws when he had time on most of the plays.

    • Rob Staton

      I didn’t see flat footed. I see someone who’s base is absolutely ideal and you want to see him plant his feet like that

      But his line was so bad it is a major concern

  10. UkAlex6674

    Rob are you doing a season prediction thread before the weekend at all please?

    • Rob Staton

      Doing a live stream tonight looking ahead to the game

© 2024 Seahawks Draft Blog

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑