Category: Front Page News (Page 41 of 367)

Will Levis & Tyler Van Dyke Week One notes

After breaking down Anthony Richardson and C.J. Stroud at the weekend, now it’s time for Will Levis and Tyler Van Dyke.

Along with Bryce Young, these five — at the moment — look like the 2023-eligible prospects with first round credentials.

Firstly, Will Levis.

I thought it was a perfectly solid start against Miami-Ohio.

His offensive line was an absolute disaster zone. I counted seven quarterback hits or sacks in the first half alone. It created an issue in the second quarter in particular and you see it impact Levis’ accuracy (which, if we’re being fair, is understandable given the barrage he faced).

Yet the things that make him a likely high pick were all on show once again.

Levis retains an excellent throwing base. His drop is rapid and consistent. He avoids the classic heel-click, plants his feet and delivers from a great foundation. The soles of his feet plant into the ground and he stays consistent in his technique.

He’s also a terrific athlete and can make the flashy little plays that just put a smile on your face. His first throw of the season was a play-action pass on the run. Off balance he just flicked his wrist, ala Aaron Rodgers, and the ball still came out with plenty of pop. It’s a small thing but for a draft geek like me — it gets you excited.

His best throw of the night came with 10:40 left in the fourth quarter. It’s a play-action pass where he dropped back to his own 30-yard line. Off-balance, without a proper base this time due to the looming pressure, he launched the ball across his body on a frozen rope to the Miami-Ohio 30-yard line, by the sideline, with perfect accuracy and velocity. The ball flew out of his hand and had the commentator declaring, ‘that’s a NFL arm right there‘. It’s that kind of play that NFL teams are going to salivate over. When you can arm-out a throw like that, off-platform, generating elite-level torque and placement — that’s what the NFL covets.

Levis showed off his arm again on his final touchdown — a rifle to the left corner of the end zone in really tight coverage. Without that arm strength, that play is defended. When he needs to drill one in, he can do it.

There are no physical limitations as a passer and he has the scrambling ability and improv to make things happen when the play breaks down.

The Senior Bowl’s Jim Nagy noted in a recent podcast that he was at the Manning Passing Academy this year and he delivered this verdict:

“To me, he (Levis) and Anthony Richardson from Florida — those two guys in terms of physical tools are probably head and shoulders above the rest of the group.”

He then made a favourable comparison to Josh Allen and Justin Herbert in terms of physical tools.

When he had time he was generally on the money. He had a superb 25-yard completion on his first drive — dropping and throwing down the seam, placing the ball away from the threatening safety and right on the chest of the receiver. He executed his first touchdown of the day shortly after, finding his tight end on a well designed play to the left corner of the end zone.

He capitalised on a great kick-return to start the second half by delivering a laser in the red zone to his receiver on a 1v1 in-cutting route. He made it look easy.

Right before half-time he side-stepped pressure in the pocket to launch a perfect pass 20-yards over the middle, hitting the receiver in stride. The throw was ideally timed, allowing the receiver to catch and run with ease, gaining an extra 25 YAC.

He looks like he’s really taken to the Shanahan-inspired offense of his new coordinator. You see all those play-action, inside slants that Kyle likes to run. He did a good job on those — and as we’ve seen with the Niners, they can be really tough to stop when you get going.

On a 4th and 2 in the first half he threw his interception in the red zone. I can’t be sure what exactly happened on this play but it looks like a major miscommunication or a botched throw. As soon as Levis delivers the ball he jumps up and down knowing something has gone wrong, anticipating the pick. The tight end throws his arms up in the air immediately, confused. It’s possible this was supposed to be a fade or a pass with a bit more loft to it and he just executed badly. It does come out of his hand a little funky. You don’t generally only show one read on a play like that and then throw it that way — it just came out clumsily. So it’s either a misunderstanding or a mistake, neither is good.

That said, I’m far less concerned by a pick like that compared to some others you see. Misreading a defender over the middle and throwing into a dangerous area (see: Bo Nix) is a lot more concerning, for example, than just something silly and avoidable like arseing up a 1v1 you like on the outside because you’re not on the same page in week one or you just F-d the throw up.

Even so, he has to get his interceptions down from last year to max out his potential. It will be something to monitor throughout the season. As erratic as Josh Allen was at Wyoming, for example, he went from 15 interceptions in 14 games in 2016 to six interceptions in 11 games in 2017. He also dropped his touchdowns down from 28 to 16 — Levis could do with finding a happier medium. I do think he can be a lesser version of Allen in the NFL. He’s a great athlete with similar traits, just on a lesser scale (Allen is a once in a generation athlete at his position, after all).

Overall, we have seen Levis play sharper and better than this. Yet I haven’t seen him play behind an O-line as bad as this and he still played fairly well. It is concerning, especially against SEC opponents, that his protection was virtually non-existent in this game. It might do more to harm his stock than anything. Yet on a technical and physical level there’s so much to like. If his protection improves he can excel and continue to elevate Kentucky and his draft stock.

His game against Anthony Richardson’s Florida next weekend will be box-office viewing for Seahawks fans, wanting a good look at the quarterback class.

Tyler Van Dyke had an extremely comfortable afternoon, unsurprisingly, against Bethune-Cookman. I think people are underestimating Miami in the ACC. They were ranked 16th nationally but it’s easy to forget how they finished last season — largely due to Van Dyke’s play. They beat Kenny Pickett and Pittsburgh in their own backyard (the eventual ACC Champions) and they could be the team to beat in the conference.

Van Dyke is such an incredibly impressive talent and it’s surprising he isn’t getting more national attention apart from the occasional placement at the end of a few first round mocks.

As with Levis, I really like his throwing base. His release is a bit more elongated than Levis’ but when he lets it rip it comes out with ideal velocity. He’s a powerhouse of a quarterback but he also shows the ability to throw with touch and precision when necessary.

His best throw was an absolute ‘wow’ moment with 13:29 left in the first half. It’s a shotgun snap and he takes a somewhat unnecessary five step drop to end up 10-yards behind the line of scrimmage. Then from a perfect throwing base he lofts a pass from the left hashmark on his own 20-yard line to the right sideline 30-yards downfield, hitting his receiver perfectly in stride while throwing over two defenders. The receiver runs it up to the 10-yard line because the throw is so ideally placed. Good route, great throw, textbook execution.

It just shows off his ability to make a difficult throw look easy, execute a big play and prove he’s not just a big arm.

If you also look at his drop — and maybe it is unnecessary — he’s a sprightly presence in the pocket. He’s very agile to manipulate a pocket or buy time. He can run for first downs when he needs to. He is not a statue. He might not be Anthony Richardson but he’s not Ryan Mallett either.

His first touchdown highlighted the advantage Miami had. Van Dyke had the fortune of being able to use an unnecessary pump fake when the Bethune-Cookman safety didn’t read the delayed wheel-route. Even so, his throw is high, safe, perfectly placed and timed. Lovely execution.

Van Dyke throws well on the run in play-action, he’s very adept at taking what’s on offer.

His touchdown with 7:32 left in the third quarter was another ‘wow’ moment. He dissects three defenders, all bunched around the receiver, and places the football in the one area he needed to for his receiver to make a catch on a seam-route to his slot-receiver. Even against an overmatched opponent, that is a wonderful looking throw.

I can’t praise him highly enough and ever since he took over the starting job a year ago, Miami have just looked like a completely different team. On his current trajectory I’d be surprised if he’s not getting serious consideration for the top-10 next year. He might be the most naturally talented passer of the ‘big five’ quarterbacks. Van Dyke’s at least in the conversation with Bryce Young for that title. He’s not the most athletic and his release might not be quite as pretty — but there is just so much to like.

There’s a bit of Carson Palmer to his game.

The great thing is there’s so much to like already about the 2023 quarterback class. With five potential first round targets already very evidently emerging — I don’t think it’s a coincidence that Seattle made the move they did this year. And it’s a reminder that short-term pain in 2022 could lead to long term gains by next April.

If you missed our Seahawks/Broncos preview stream yesterday, check it out here:

And if you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, why not consider supporting the site via Patreon? (click the tab below)

Become a Patron!

The problem with C.J. Stroud

I stayed up until 5am to watch a recording of Notre Dame vs Ohio State, purposefully to watch C.J. Stroud.

It was more of the same from last year.

It’s obvious he is going to ‘wow’ a whole bunch of teams at his pro-day because his physical tools are obvious. He can get out of the pocket and throw off-balance and from different angles. The way he contorts his body and delivers from difficult launch points is very mondern-NFL.

He will no doubt do the one thing all QB’s do at pro-day nowadays in shorts and a T-shirt — run one way then throw across his body, against the grain, downfield. That clip will go viral, everyone on twitter will go nuts and some NFL scouts and coaches will be smitten.

However, his accuracy and consistency remains a big issue and I continue to wonder if he isn’t just a great big tease.

Stroud lost Garrett Wilson and Chris Olave to the draft this year — both were top-12 picks. In the early exchanges he also lost likely first rounder Jaxon Smith-Njigba. Without his arsenal of great weapons, there were some struggles early against Notre Dame. He seemed to lose composure and he toiled.

His timing was off, he threw behind and high. There were late throws. Granted there were occasions where receivers could’ve made his life easier too by settling down in zone and simply presenting a target. Yet you couldn’t help but notice the number of passes sailing off target.

At one point he was 11/13 for 82 yards on underneath throws (-10 yards) and 1/7 for 21 yards on +10 yard throws. The easy dump-offs were working but barely anything else was.

He settled down a bit in the second half, lobbing a nice seam-pass for a crucial touchdown — but there were still some misses.

I can’t help but think we’ve seen this before. A toolsy Ohio State QB with everything delivered on a plate. Favourable scheme, loads of weapons, physical tools. A player with talent but he can’t put it all together to be a rounded, competent quarterback.

The way he managed this game was in stark contrast to Florida’s Anthony Richardson. He seemed in complete command of his offense and played the percentages. It was a lot more up-and-down for Stoud.

His short and intermediate game isn’t great and that’s where the accuracy problems show up the most. His awareness on third and medium isn’t great, unlike Richardson who knew to throw beyond the sticks to move the chains. His timing was off, he missed the mark too often and his screen passes would fit perfectly in Seattle in that they’re not very good.

The other side to the story though is Justin Herbert. At Oregon, he also had all the tools but was wildly erratic and underwhelming. He was stuck in a boring offense that required him to check-down and throw bubble-screens and short slants galore. We never got to see Herbert at his best (and I fear Tyler Van Dyke will be similarly restricted under the same coaching staff, now in Miami).

Yet once Herbert arrived in the NFL he took off. Playing in a more progressive offense that really showed off his physical tools — he became one of the stars of the league. He was unleashed. It’s not out of the question Stroud could do the same thing.

That’s the big question for Stroud. Is he another Herbert? After all, Herbert had 15 interceptions last year despite his blossoming stock. It’s not hard to imagine Stroud having some of the same issues but also some of the same positives as Herbert. And who wouldn’t take that? I’m not saying he is Herbert. I’m just trying to offset my concerns with the other side of what needs to be considered with Stroud.

To that extent, he’s in a similar boat to Will Levis — who I also think can be a Herbert type at the next level. I think there’s a bit more magic to Levis and it’s harder to elevate Kentucky than it is to win with Ohio State. He’s also coming from a pro-style offense working with a McVay disciple and now a Shanahan coach.

Both players will be debated for their pro’s and con’s a lot and probably analysed more than the other QB’s eligible for 2023. Bryce Young, eventually, is going to be viewed as a 5-9, 190lbs thrower without the sturdiness of other shorter QB’s (Brees, Wilson, Murray). Van Dyke is a fantastic player and should get more attention. Richardson, after his performance last night — will be the toast of the town this week. If he continues to perform the way he did on Sunday, the sky’s the limit for him.

For Stroud — I think perception is greater than reality at the moment. He will be one of the tougher players to analyse pre-draft. Do you believe in the physical upside enough to imagine he can star in the pro’s? Or is he going to be just too erratic and inconsistent to ever deliver on his potential?

After one week of college football, Florida’s Richardson would lead a draftable quarterback power-ranking. I have watched Levis vs Miami-Ohio and I thought he was terrific, despite the porous offensive line he was playing behind and what appeared to be a miscommunication on an interception. Other than that, he showed off his NFL arm and ability to drive the ball and make difficult pro-level throws look easy.

Ohio State play four home games to start the season. They next face powderpuff outings against Arkansas State and Toledo and then host Wisconsin. They won’t face a truly difficult test until Michigan on November 26th.

Stroud’s biggest showcase until Michigan came in his opening game. His team won — but it wasn’t a convincing performance.

If you missed my notes on Anthony Richardson and a host of other quarterbacks yesterday, click here.

And if you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, why not consider supporting the site via Patreon? (click the tab below)

Become a Patron!

Quarterback watch: Anthony Richardson wows vs Utah

Anthony Richardson impresses

It was hard to know what to do with Richardson going into this season. For someone with only 64 pass attempts to his name, he was getting a lot of attention in the media. Mel Kiper, for example, was projecting him as a first round pick.

It’s impossible to project a quarterback that high when they’d done so little in college. Especially when his stat-line — six touchdowns to five interceptions — was mediocre.

However, Kiper often relays what he’s hearing rather than seeing. Thus, it felt like the league had their eye firmly on Richardson.

Today, it was obvious why. This was a particularly impressive opener.

The game overall was terrific. It had a bit of everything. Explosive plays, creative quarterbacks, hard-nosed running, big defensive plays and ebbs and flows throughout.

It was hard not to be drawn to Utah tight end Brant Kuithe. He had nine catches for 105 yards and a touchdown — excelling against the top-level SEC athletes on Florida’s defense to consistently get open. He is a name to watch going forward.

Yet Richardson stole the show with four quarters of mature, composed, explosive football.

Billy Napier has introduced a modern pro-style offense to Florida. There’s a lot of misdirection, motion and play-action. It’d be easy, in the first game, for a young quarterback to be a little overwhelmed and make basic errors — especially against a tough opponent like Utah.

Richardson’s processing was virtually flawless with the exception of one blip. He showed total control in play action and was calm and collected in the pocket. He knew when to take off and the specific coverages that would afford him space to run as the play broke down.

He throws with real velocity and punch. He completed several comfortable throws over the middle, going to a second read, to move the chains. He managed the game how it needed to be managed.

When he needed to be creative he produced magic. This included a spectacular 45-yard touchdown run where he weaved his way through the Utah defensive line then turned on the jets to sprint to the end-zone. It was part opportunism, part understanding of the coverage Utah were playing and the space he was running into.

On a vital two-point conversion late in the game he spun away from an attempted tackle with almost a majesty — creating the time and space to fire into the right corner of the end zone. Without that play, Utah probably kick a game winning field goal shortly after.

He also had a terrific scramble play earlier in the drive on 4th and 3 to make a conversion.

Richardson clearly possesses great physical tools. Arm strength, speed. He’s 6-4 and 232lbs. He can improvise. He extends plays and is a real threat with his legs. You’d like to see consistent evidence of accurate touch throws to complement the tools but hopefully that will come as he plays more games.

What he showed here, however, was maturity. This was — it has to be said — a game for a ‘Pete Carroll’ type of quarterbacking performance. It wasn’t a three touchdown, 400-yard game. It was a stay on time, produce in the moment and be the difference maker.

The only time it almost went south for Richardson was an ill-advised scramble on 3rd and 11 with 5:18 left in the third quarter. He had a misread on an open receiver, scrambled away from heavy pressure and forced a bad throw into coverage that should’ve been intercepted. It was a let-off — but the only time in the game you could say he made a serious error.

He finished the game 17/24 for 168 yards, adding 104 rushing yards on 11 carries and three rushing touchdowns.

Based on this performance, he does have legit first round talent.

He will face some interesting challenges coming up. Next week he goes head-to-head with Will Levis and Kentucky. He also has a three-game stretch against LSU, Georgia and Texas A&M at the end of October.

One game isn’t enough to make any bold declarations and we need to see more. He’s in the conversation though and one to monitor. In recent years, Joe Burrow and Zach Wilson looked great early in the season and ended up being a #1 and #2 pick.

If Richardson keeps playing like this — in a pro-offense — he will appeal greatly to the NFL and specifically to Seattle.

Carroll will want an explosive, exciting player who can help the running game with his mobility and speed but also have the mental capacity to manage key situations. We all know he wants a point guard who doesn’t turn the ball over. It’s hard to play that way and still be explosive. Richardson at least has the physical potential to pull it off — and this game was evidence he has the mental processing to match.

This was a good start and the sky is the limit for Richardson if he keeps it up.

Other notes

— C.J. Stroud had a very C.J. Stroud type of performance. He is a very up-and-down player. Once Jaxon Smith-Njigba left the game early with an injury, the offense stuttered. Suddenly he didn’t have his three key receivers from a year ago. He became jittery and inaccurate. At one point he was 11/13 for 82 yards on underneath throws (-10 yards) and 1/7 for 21 yards on +10 yard throws. He threw high, he threw behind, he threw late. Yet he also flashed at times. He threw a nice touchdown down the seam to take a lead Ohio State never lost. He threw especially well on the run — contorting his body to throw from challenging angles, twisting to generate velocity. He’ll no doubt be able to pull off that pro-day throw everyone loves throwing against the grain in shorts. So the physical tools are there — he’s just streaky.

— It was an easy start for Miami and Tyler Van Dyke as they despatched Bethune-Cookman 70-13. TVD finished 13/16 passing for 192 yards and two scores. Job done in week one for a very impressive player who should be on your first round radar.

— Will Levis had a couple of hairy moments including a red-zone interception but Kentucky ended up comfortably beating Miami-Ohio 37-13. Levis finished 21/32 for 303 yards with three touchdowns and one pick. He suffered a number of dropped passes. He needs to keep the interception numbers down after 13 last year. There’s so much to like about his physical tools though. This little flick looks easy but it isn’t. He has sky-high potential.

— It was a predictably easy day for Bryce Young and Alabama. They hammered poor Utah State 55-0 with Young scoring five passing touchdowns (18/28, 195 yards) and one rushing touchdown (5 runs, 100 yards).

— I like Dorian Thompson-Robinson at UCLA. Not for round one but certainly someone who deserves more attention. He had a spectacular 68-yard touchdown scramble in a 45-17 win against Bowling Green. He finished 32/43 passing for 298 yards (two touchdowns, one pick). The brilliant Zach Charbonnet ran for 111 yards on 21 carries, also scoring a touchdown.

— I think Arkansas’ KJ Jefferson is being overrated by a lot of people but he had a solid opener against Cincinnati — going 18/26 for 223 yards and three scores. He also ran for a touchdown. I don’t see him as a likely first round prospect.

— At no point have I ever been convinced Spencer Rattler is a first round prospect — even when the hype was out of control a year ago. Today he made his debut for South Carolina and threw two interceptions against Georgia State. He trusts his arm way too much and just cannot process. He completed 23/37 for 227 yards and had only one passing touchdown.

— Tanner McKee was also a bit underwhelming with a 22/27 for 308 passing yards stat-line against Colgate. He had two passing touchdowns and one interception. He had a really nice game against Oregon a year ago but there’s a lot of bad tape out there too.

— BYU’s Jaren Hall — another player I think is a bit overrated — completed 25/32 for 261 yards against South Florida. He had two touchdowns and one pick.

College football open thread & notes

Here we go then. The start of the most important draft season in franchise history.

Why is it so important? When’s the last time the franchise traded away a star quarterback? The judgement of that trade will be made based on Russell Wilson’s success in Denver, plus whatever Seattle does with their draft picks next year.

The next few months are absolutely critical. This is the start of a marathon. I intend to watch multiple college games per week with a specific focus on quarterbacks.

This is an open thread to discuss everything. I will post some review notes later.

Here are the games I am watching over the weekend:

Colorado vs Michigan
Oregon vs Georgia
Utah vs Florida
Notre Dame vs Ohio State
Florida State vs LSU

I will also be watching Clemson vs Georgia Tech on Monday.

Quarterback watch

Will Levis and Kentucky start today at home to Miami-Ohio. Their first big test will be next weekend at Florida.

Tyler Van Dyke begins against Bethune-Cookman. In two weeks time Miami goes to Texas A&M which will be interesting.

It’s a great test first up for C.J. Stroud and I’ll be watching Notre Dame vs Ohio State closely (like most people, presumably).

Bryce Young and Alabama start the season against Utah State.

These are the four names to keep an eye on, in my opinion.

On the fringes of the discussion, hoping to emerge, will be Anthony Richardson. Hopefully he gets more than 66 throws this year so we can get a good look at him. I’ll be watching him vs Utah in a good contest first-up.

I have no faith in Spencer Rattler but his South Carolina debut is against Georgia State.

I’m interested to see how Dorian Thompson-Robinson gets on for UCLA this year. He faces Bowling Green today. Another PAC-12 quarterback, Stanford’s Tanner McKee, takes on Colgate.

The hype for Arkansas quarterback K.J. Jefferson is way too rich for my liking but Arkansas play a much-changed Cincinnati in their opener.

I’ll be looking out for other quarterback prospects too. My pre-2022 season reviews of the entire QB class can be found here.

And if you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, why not consider supporting the site via Patreon? (click the tab below)

Become a Patron!

Thoughts on the Seahawks 53-man roster

Stop me if you’ve heard this already — but I’m ready and prepared for a tough season. You’ve just got to embrace it.

2022 is about college football. It’s about quarterbacks. It’s about getting to the end of the NFL year and treating it like it’s a half-marathon you’ve not really trained for.

I fear, however, that some Seahawks fans are seeing things differently. That while they’re not quite getting their hopes up — they’re allowing themselves to view the roster Seattle announced yesterday as worthy of some optimism.

I feel the opposite.

It looks bad.

So much work needs to be done.

I think the roster is some way off what they had even in 2011.

That shouldn’t be a surprise. This is year one of the rebuild. It was year two in 2011. The difference this time is they weren’t starting from an expansion franchise-level team they inherited from Tim Ruskell. Yet the depth and gold-standard talent is missing and they haven’t drafted or signed the entire LOB, added Marshawn Lynch or brought in the likes of K.J. Wright and various others.

I’ve seen several people argue in the comments section here and on my YouTube channel about what the Seahawks have.

A chap called Aaron, for example, posted the following:

“Every skill position on the offense minus the QB has star power in the starters. I understand there’s a depth issue here, but you have to give them the offensive talent. It’s there. You put any true top 10 QB on this squad and the offense becomes elite.”

The word ‘elite’ is used so liberally these days.

When you strip it down, things become a bit more realistic.

I’m not for a second suggesting everyone is rubbish or there isn’t any hope for the future. Yet I think we need to analyse what they actually have.

Let’s start with the offense.

D.K. Metcalf is an excellent player but I still think he has a ways to go to reach the top of the game at his position. Tyler Lockett is clearly an excellent and reliable player. Yet these two — who aren’t supported by much else at receiver — will be reliant on Geno Smith throwing the football in 2022.

Arguably Seattle’s two best players will be hamstrung by the quarterback situation and this could hamper their impact potential.

The tight end group is very much a question mark. Will Dissly may be a solid blocker but in 31 games over the last two seasons he’s accumulated only 482 yards and three touchdowns. Noah Fant has had an underwhelming career so far and Colby Parkinson has shown very little in the game time he’s been afforded.

I’m excited to see if Rashaad Penny can continue his form at the end of last season and I really like Ken Walker. Yet Penny still has to prove he can stay healthy and produce for a longer period than a brief flourish at the end of his contract year. Walker has a hernia that Pete Carroll is being worryingly evasive about. Right now, I just want him to be available.

It’s been pleasing to see Travis Homer and Deejay Dallas look brighter in pre-season than previous years but it’s hard to muster much enthusiasm if either is thrust into extended playing time.

On the offensive line there’s plenty of promise at offensive tackle but that’s what it is. Promise and hope for the future. This is fine — you don’t expect any more than that from rookie tackles. Growing pains are inevitable though and there might be some ugly moments this season. We just have to give them time and hope they can develop into good, quality players. They will probably not start their careers at that level — probably far from it.

And then there’s the quarterback situation. I know some people have convinced themselves that Geno Smith can be adequate. The cold, stark reality is Geno Smith is still, believe it or not, Geno Smith. The only alternative remains Drew Lock. The people suggesting this is the worst quarterback room in the league have a valid point.

That’s the offense. If we were reflecting on this unit for a NFC West foe, we’d be grinning from ear to ear.

It’s all about the rookie tackles bedding in and a running game being sustained to set the table for the future. That has to be the hope and the aim. If the running game isn’t strong and consistent, this unit could have major, major problems and the quarterback — unlike previous years — will not be there to bail you out.

On defense, the unit lacks stars. The hope is that someone like Darrell Taylor can emerge as one but the truth is we just don’t know. He showed tremendous promise in 2021 but going from what we saw last year to even a 2018 Frank Clark level player is a big step. Let’s hope he can show it.

They have a collection of big-bodied interior defenders but lack a truly disruptive pass rusher in the middle. I’m not convinced Uchenna Nwosu will be a difference maker. Alton Robinson deserves a chance to (finally) show what he can do but will he ever get it? Boye Mafe — while filled with talent and potential — will likely experience the same ups and downs as the young offensive tackles.

There is a chance in the future that Taylor and Mafe could be a frightening double-act. Again though, it’s more hope than guarantee at this point. The Seahawks are trying to develop players to solve a long-lasting problem (X-factor pass rushers). It’s good that they have two projects but the reality is they won’t start the season with a proven blue-chip defensive lineman.

Linebacker depth is bizarrely thin. Big things are expected of Jordyn Brooks but I still think he has a lot to prove — especially now that Bobby Wagner has moved on. If he was to get injured, it could be a crisis without an obvious solution.

In the secondary, the cornerbacks are already banged up and hurting. Michael Jackson has been the big winner in pre-season and should get a start. The two rookies — Coby Bryant and Tariq Woolen — are showing promise. Yet, once again, there’s very little proven quality here. It’s just more hope and optimism that answers will emerge.

At safety you have a very solid, dependable player in Quandre Diggs but not someone who is going to necessarily tilt games in your favour. Then there’s Jamal Adams — a player who might well have already had the best days of his career. He’s often injured and facing a make-or-break season. It’s fair to call that trade an expensive disaster so far. It’s hard to invest any faith in Adams staying healthy, let alone providing the big impact his price-tag demands.

As with the offense, there’s some young hope for the future but not enough big-time talent to feel confident projecting this as a unit that can have major success. Throw in a rookie defensive coordinator and some changes to the scheme — and it might also be some time before everyone settles into a rhythm. It’s been so long since the Seahawks rushed the passer properly and turned the ball over regularly you’d be forgiven for wondering if they remember how to do it.

Finally, special teams. Jason Myers continues to hint that his one-good year in 2020 was an outlier while the kick coverage was appalling in pre-season. For a team looking to play close to the vest this season, this wasn’t a good sign.

For me this roster looks ripe to struggle. I suspect this team is somewhere between 2010 and 2011. Remember — in 2010 they already had Russell Okung, Earl Thomas, Chris Clemons and Marshawn Lynch. They had experience at quarterback and a few other experienced players. But it was year-one of a rebuild so they had some big weak areas too (a bit like this year).

They won seven games in 2010 but let’s not forget four of those wins came from within a division Seattle won at 7-9. They also defeated the 2-14 Carolina Panthers.

They have no such luxury this year. The NFC West is much harder. There probably won’t be four wins to claim. They might be able to find them elsewhere against the likes of the Lions, Falcons, Jets and Giants — although it’s a stretch to think they’ll win all of their perceived ‘winnable’ games.

Contests against the Chiefs, Buccs and Chargers could be terrifying experiences.

For what it’s worth — and I may live to regret saying this — I kind of fancy them in week one against Denver. I could see them pulling off an upset. Admittedly, I can also see a very long evening too. It should be a fascinating game.

This roster has the look of a team primed to pick in the top five or six in 2023 and I don’t think first or second overall is out of the question.

I’m perfectly comfortable with that. They need another draft to add more talent because there simply isn’t enough right now. Short term pain for longer term gain has always been the best approach this year after trading Russell Wilson. I’m tempted to give them credit for committing to it by sticking to their guns at quarterback. It would’ve been easy enough to make some half-baked trade to marginally upgrade. This almost looks like a stoic, disciplined commitment to mediocrity. Either that or complete misplaced confidence.

I sense fans overly familiar with certain players are elevating the roster to a level that is unwarranted and I fear those same fans will react accordingly when things don’t go as they expect.

They need so much more. This could be ugly.

My suggestion would be to embrace it and look forward to the return of college football and the start of the biggest draft season this franchise has arguably ever had.

If you missed it yesterday check out my piece on the non-quarterback prospects eligible for the 2023 draft.

And if you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, why not consider supporting the site via Patreon? (click the tab below)

Become a Patron!

2023 draft preview — the non-quarterbacks

Bryan Bresee — very, very impressive

Since the decision to trade Russell Wilson, I’ve set about watching every 2021 game of the four main 2023 eligible quarterbacks (at least in my opinion) — Will Levis, Tyler Van Dyke, Bryce Young and C.J. Stroud.

I’ve also watched a decent chunk of all of the other bigger name quarterbacks. This is clearly going to be the focus for the blog (and the wider fan base) for the next few months.

That said, the other positions will have a big say in how this all plays out. For me, the best three players in terms of talent and potential are not quarterbacks.

Neither is the 2023 quarterback class an otherworldly, once in a generation, can’t-miss group. There are some intriguing players and others can emerge. Yet there are two defensive linemen, for example, that I think could be special very early in their NFL careers.

These are all things to consider as we move forward.

I spent the last three weeks watching non-quarterbacks to form opinions before the start of the new college football season.

The three best players eligible for 2023

Will Anderson (DE, Alabama)
Bryan Bresee (DT, Clemson)
Bijan Robinson (RB, Texas)

When I watched this trio, they all appear to have legit star quality. They look like blue-chippers with the potential to come into the league and be brilliant very quickly.

Everyone knows about Will Anderson by now. He is the best pass rusher to enter the league since Myles Garrett and might be even better. He had an astonishing 33.5 TFL’s in 2021 alone, along with 17.5 sacks. Those are practically unbelievable numbers, even taking into consideration he plays for Alabama.

Anderson has everything — an ideal frame, power, quickness, attitude, leadership, intensity, twitch. I don’t think it’s a coincidence he wears #31 (Kam Chancellor’s number) because he plays with the same physicality.

He’s a special, special player — a legit #1 overall pick in any draft. It’s distinctly possible that a team needing a quarterback will draft him instead because he’s just too good. We’re talking about the Andrew Luck of pass rushers here.

Bryan Bresee isn’t far behind in terms of talent, although his situation is different. He suffered an ACL injury a year ago and we’ll need to see how he comes back from that. His tape, however, is a sight to behold.

Considering he’s 6-5 and 300lbs, his athleticism and mobility are sensational and constantly flash on tape. He’s extremely active and runs like a player weighing 270lbs. He slips blocks to knife into the backfield, he works across the line with ease and he can be unblockable. Bresee plays with violent hands and he shows explosive qualities in his lower body. His effort and intensity is top notch and he plays with a fantastic motor. He’s nicknamed ‘The Hulk’ by his team mates.

I watched some practise tape from Clemson to watch him in 1v1 situations and ended up rubbing my eyes at this one move he pulled — engaging the blocker, spinning away from his grasp and then just exploding and accelerating. It was like watching a top-level speed rusher — yet he’s 300lbs.

At SPARQ he ran an eye-watering 4.21 short shuttle at 290lbs and also jumped a 31 inch vertical. He was the top SPARQ tester among all defensive tackles in his year group.

For me, Bresee has the potential to be the next great interior rusher. Those are so rare these days, it won’t be a surprise if he goes in the same range as Ndamukong Suh and Gerald McCoy. He does need to prove he’s fully recovered from the injury though (and can stay healthy).

Twenty years ago, Bijan Robinson would’ve been a top-five lock. Nowadays he’ll likely suffer because of the way the running back position is viewed. However — we still see top-rated runners go in the top-10 and I think there’s a legit chance someone will take Robinson in that range next year.

He has a wow-factor on tape and looks close to perfection as a running back prospect. There have been some hyped-up running backs in the last decade but arguably none showed the complete game Robinson possesses. The way he cuts and changes direction is better than any runner I’ve covered since starting this blog in 2008. He looks, at times, like a better version of a pre-injury Nick Chubb at Georgia.

Robinson has the ideal frame and combines explosive power and physicality with fantastic acceleration. He breaks tackles and gains yards after contact but he also has the ability to cut on a dime and just accelerate like a Formula 1 car. If anyone gets near him, he delivers a violent stiff-arm. He can get the hard yards and he can hit home runs.

Whatever your view on the running back position — watching him is a treat.

I am not suggesting these three players will go 1-2-3. However, I would suggest they are the best three players I have scouted ahead of the start of the new season.

Other players with first round potential

Trenton Simpson (LB, Clemson)
Jalen Carter (DT, Georgia)
Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR, Ohio State)
Michael Mayer (TE, Notre Dame)
Kelee Ringo (CB, Georgia)

Trenton Simpson is the ideal linebacker for an attack minded defensive scheme that wants to send a lot of pressure in exotic blitz packages. He’s said to be 6-3 and 240lbs but I’m not sold on that. Simpson supposedly has 6% body fat and can run in the 4.3’s with a sub-1.5 10-yard split.

It’s that combination of incredible athleticism and quickness that stands out on tape. You can line him up as the extra man off the edge and he’s a heat-seeking missile to the passer. He blitzes with a real purpose and determination. He has shown the ability to put offensive tackles on skates with his sheer will and desire to make a play and his raw speed and agility means he eats up ground and changes direction so quickly — he’s difficult to grapple.

I love Simpson’s fire and he can be a big-time tone-setter for a unit. He’s not just a blitzer though. There are snaps on tape where he lines up in the slot and breaks up passes. He’s willing to fill a gap on short yardage runs.

The only question is will his aggressive, attack-minded approach translate to the next level against better opponents? And is he only a fit in very specific schemes? There’s so much to like though and he could be a big time player in the 2023 draft.

Jalen Carter felt like a less spectacular version of Bryan Bresee. He loves a swim move and he’s very good at it. Carter shows an ability to swim away from blockers then burst to the QB. I don’t think he’s as athletic, physical or as active as Bresee but he’s capable of putting interior blockers into bad positions with his angles and then winning with superior movement and power.

He was respected enough to receive a fair dose of double teams, even on Georgia’s loaded D-line. His get-off is highly impressive at times. Carter also has a violent rip and punch leading into the swim. He shows impressive mobility on stunts when he has to travel — hinting at plus athleticism. He has a good understanding of leverage with his hands and positioning. He has a chance to be a first round pick.

Jaxon Smith-Njigba is just an incredible player who could take the NFL by storm. I just want to see his testing numbers before committing to that, because he only ran a 4.64 at SPARQ. Nevertheless, I thought he was Ohio State’s best receiver last year and the two guys starting with him both went in the top-15.

Highly drafted tight ends have a tendency to disappoint and that might play against Michael Mayer. However, he looks second only to Georgia’s Brock Bowers in terms of potential in college football. He’s a very rounded player but also an X-factor in the passing game and should be viewed as a likely first rounder (again depending on testing results).

My Kelee Ringo notes were pretty limited but telling. He looks the part. He’s big (6-2, 215lbs), long, physical and is said to be a legit 4.3 runner. Enough said.

Other players worth discussing

Myles Murphy (DE, Clemson) is a big power end but he doesn’t win with speed. He shoots gaps and wins with hand-use and power. I’m not convinced he has the twitch to be a first rounder and I feel like we’ve seen this type of prospect a lot over the years — a big name who ends up on day two because he doesn’t have the splash and the quickness to trouble offensive tackles off the edge. He just doesn’t seem all that spectacular to me. Is he a difference maker? Not sure.

Derrick Hall (DE, Auburn) is a very active pass rusher who can engage/disengage and finish. He’s shown glimpses of a power rush but can dip and straighten quite well too. He lacks top-level bend but has some quickness for a well-built frame. I like his intensity and he plays to the whistle. He’s not the twitchiest though and there’s some stiffness there. I think he’s likely a day-two type.

Isaiah Foskey (LB, Notre Dame) has busy hands and despite a lack of size he can work to control blocks with jab-jab punches. He doesn’t have elite quicks but can work a path to the QB and he’s tough to stop when he bends the arc. Foskey is capable of controlling blocks with his left arm, leaving his right arm free to swipe at the ball if possible or read the play — creating freedom to react and process. He has shown ability to slap hands down to win leverage battles. He’ll be very scheme-specific but he could be a menace as a 3-4 OLB.

Steele Chambers (LB, Ohio State) is very comfortable in coverage and moves with great fluidity. He can read a pass play, know which area to drop into and play the ball. He’s undersized but active at the LOS. He won’t fit every team but has a knack for making plays.

Jack Campbell (LB, Iowa) looks big, stiff, carries a lot of blocks and I wanted to see a lot more than I did on tape.

Will McDonald (DE, Iowa State) is raw AF but his potential will have teams salivating. He’s only 236lbs (can he get up to 250?) but he supposedly can jump a 42 inch vertical. If you let him rush the edge he can do what teams want — bend and straighten to the QB. He looks athletic and he can deceive blockers with a subtle drop of the shoulder or a shimmy at the POA. McDonald looks long and lean and teams are going to see him as a bit of a prototype.

However, I also saw snaps where he struggles to disengage against tight ends. He overextends and leans into too many engagements. He also plays with effort but lacks any kind of mean streak. I think he could go early, though, with teams believing he can be something of a sack specialist early in his career as he works to become more rounded.

I didn’t see anything to get excited about with Tyree Wilson (DE, Texas Tech). He appears to lack twitch off the edge. There are some decent bull rushes on tape but it was a pretty ‘meh’ experience watching him.

Mazi Smith (DT, Michigan) controls blockers up front. It’s extremely rare that he loses a 1v1. He shows evidence of being able to slip blocks and penetrate which is good for his role as a nose tackle. He can contain the interior to provide opportunities for others. It was great to see him chase after screen passes like a much smaller man. He’s the ideal anchor up front, is expected to test well and he could be a day two prospect as an interior stopper.

If you missed it a few months ago — here is my big article on the 2023 eligible quarterbacks. I’ve watched a lot more of these players than most — so if you’re looking for a QB guide going into the new season, it’s worth checking out.

Plus if you missed my live stream with Jeff Simmons yesterday, you can watch it here:

And if you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, why not consider supporting the site via Patreon? (click the tab below)

Become a Patron!

Some thoughts after the Dallas game

Earlier this week I posted a video explaining why I think the Seahawks will now go after Jimmy Garoppolo.

Watching the final pre-season game makes me more convinced than ever that this is what they’ll do.

Geno Smith has been named the starter almost by default. Look at his pre-season. He has played in three games and delivered just one touchdown drive. That’s despite playing two whole halves of football against Pittsburgh and Chicago’s backups.

In this game against Dallas, they even gave him Tyler Lockett to try and get something working. Yet it still ended with a back-breaking sack leading to a field goal.

Sam Williams, just as he did in college, had Charles Cross’ lunch money. Yet some of the blame goes to the quarterback. He took an age to get rid of the ball. That play easily could’ve knocked them out of field goal range. He had to get rid of the football.

He also has a knack for wandering into trouble when he panics in the pocket.

That was him done for the night and the pre-season. A thoroughly mediocre, fairly miserable experience for anyone who witnessed it.

I continue to believe that the New Orleans game last season, rather than the Jacksonville one, is the reality of a Smith-led offense. And I think the Seahawks know it too.

As the ‘leader in the clubhouse’ in this quarterback race, Smith hasn’t had to press. It was clear in this game that Drew Lock felt he had to do something drastic and it led to mind-numbing errors.

Lock deserves criticism — especially for the second pick. Yet I couldn’t help but feel like he was set up for a night like this. Despite Carroll’s insistence to the contrary — Smith has had the vast bulk of the training camp snaps with the #1 offense. Lock’s untimely illness meant he played in one fewer pre-season game too.

Smith has been able to play ‘not to lose the job’. If the Seahawks are looking for someone to do the basics, how was Lock ever going to show that from his second-ranked position? If he’d played a safe old game of football against Dallas, he wasn’t winning the gig. He knew he had to shine and go above and beyond.

It’d be very easy to suggest this has been no serious competition. And for that reason, I’m inclined to give Lock some sympathy for what happened as he made ill-advised throws and pressed like crazy.

However, he blew any hopes of starting with that performance. It was ugly. It was exactly what he showed at Missouri and Denver. He is wildly erratic — capable of brilliant throws and torturous mistakes.

Smith isn’t good enough. Lock is too erratic. All signs point to them going after Garoppolo to see if he can produce more than Smith is capable of.

I know the replies to this article will be calls to simply ‘suck with Smith’ for a draft pick. As also noted earlier in the week — I am comfortable with that but I’m not sure Carroll can afford that. If the Seahawks start badly against Denver, the pressure ramps up. His legacy comes into question. He’ll be portrayed as the man who ran the franchise quarterback out of town and then produced an appalling product.

If they continue to play poorly — and if Russell Wilson excels with the Broncos — that noise will grow even more.

The Seahawks do not communicate well with their fans. The owner never speaks. Carroll has spent months insisting this isn’t a rebuild — when all he had to do was be honest to fans. The team has traded a franchise legend (and cut another). The aim is to compete like crazy in 2022 but admittedly, this is a process that will require a bit of time (and some patience).

Carroll’s words — no rebuild, ‘we have two #1 quarterbacks’, ‘Lock is really good’, ‘Geno Smith was awesome when he started last year’, ‘the two quarterbacks have had the same number of reps/opportunities in camp’ — has felt like another example, sadly, of insulting our intelligence.

It’s on a par with ‘the Wilson trade talk is a media creation’ from a year ago — followed by telling the local media over and over again it was a non-story, thus making people look silly when the trade eventually happened.

It’ll be interesting to see if the members of the media impacted by that will be less inclined to sympathise with the Seahawks if this season goes south.

Can’t we just have a bit of honesty from Carroll for once? I feel like I’ve been listening to a desperate politician for too long. I’m ready for some straight talking. I’m ready, as a fan, to be treated with a bit of respect.

That doesn’t mean coming out and announcing, ‘yeah, we’re trash’. There are ways and means of handling this beyond the nonsense (‘we have two #1 QB’s’) that we’ve heard so far.

Because this looks, to me, like a team that is going to really struggle in 2022. I say that while also believing there’s a good chance for some typical NFL magic in week one against Denver. If that game was being played in week six, I think Denver wins at a canter. Kudos to the NFL for making it week one — increasing the chances of an upset win, in front of a jacked-up crowd.

Regardless, this team looks bad. People inclined to not hear any criticism of the Seahawks ever (and they are back out in force, sadly) will say it’s pre-season, it’s premature etc.

I think we can tell. I think they are scrambling around trying to piece this together. They have treated pre-season differently to other teams — keeping starters on the field for longer for the purpose of figuring things out. Yes — other key names have been rested. But there’s been a competitive element — an importance — to this pre-season in Seattle that other teams simply didn’t have in 2022.

And the Seahawks have been rubbish.

I think the best case scenario for this team is a 2011-style rough start and strong finish — which would be fine but isn’t a given.

And again — I’m comfortable with a bad year to gain draft position. I am, however, unsure whether I want to endure two or three more years of Carroll just because it’s convenient for the owners before a sale. It just feels like this is a franchise that needs a fresh start. I think this pre-season, and this QB competition, shows that.

I’ll happily admit if I’m wrong when the season starts.

I think Carroll knows he has to show some positivity on the field to keep the fans on board. And that’s why I think Garoppolo arrives next week, with the objective of replacing Geno Smith if/when he produces mediocre results.

It might not make them a good team. But it might help them avoid being terrible. And that’s probably what they want — to get into the 2023 draft without completely collapsing into a 3-4 win franchise.

My other thoughts on the Dallas game are limited to these notes:

— Myles Adams needs to make the team. He’s been very disruptive in pre-season and looks like a heck of a player. A good find and well done to Clint Hurtt and the staff for helping him reach a new level in pre-season.

— The depth at receiver is shocking. I think they spent their money very poorly in free agency and a better WR3 was required. This will likely be a draft priority again next year, I sense.

— Abraham Lucas is the real deal. It was ridiculous he lasted to round three. What an absolute steal for the Seahawks and an inspired selection.

— Alton Robinson has flashed enough to again make you question — what the heck have they been doing with this guy for the last couple of years?

— The depth on this team is concerning. They are a Jordyn Brooks injury, for example, away from catastrophe at linebacker (in my opinion). It just feels like a front heavy roster with some young talent we hope develops — then not a lot else.

— Does anyone else just think this is going to be another year where the Seahawks don’t make the most of their tight ends?

Anyway, roll on the real football. I’ve got an article coming up looking at my favourite non-QB draft prospects for 2023 (with notes on a few other players too). So stay tuned for that on Monday.

If you enjoy the content on Seahawks Draft Blog, please consider supporting us via Patreon (click the tab below)…

Become a Patron!

« Older posts Newer posts »

© 2025 Seahawks Draft Blog

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑