
Carlos Dunlap must be brought back by the Seahawks
Enough is enough.
This needs sorting now.
It’s quite incredible that a week into free agency, the Seahawks are nearing an inglorious hat-trick.
For the last two years, they’ve done an appalling job addressing their pass rush.
In 2019 they traded Frank Clark before the draft and insufficiently replaced him. They forced themselves to reach for L.J. Collier, when preferred options were off the board. They then took a huge gamble on Ziggy Ansah’s surgically repaired shoulder.
By the time the pre-season came around, they were starting Cassius Marsh, Barkevious Mingo and Jacob Martin as their top pass rushers.
The Jadeveon Clowney trade bailed them out somewhat — yet he basically ran a one-man show in 2019.
The Seahawks finished with 28 sacks, second fewest in the league behind only Miami (23). Their sack percentage was 4.5% — third worst overall.
They had only 126 pressures, sixth fewest in the league behind Detroit (125), Oakland (117), Houston (117), Atlanta (115) and Miami (96). Seattle’s pressure percentage was the fourth worst in the league (19.3%) behind Detroit (18.9%), Houston (18.1%) and Miami (16.7%).
It was a mess.
They entered the 2020 off-season saying fixing the pass rush was the key — stating retaining Clowney was a priority.
Yet the unpredictable nature of Clowney’s approach to free agency caught them off guard. They found themselves stuck between a rock and a hard place. Do you move off Clowney, potentially missing the chance to re-sign him down the line? Or do you keep waiting, missing out on alternative options?
In the end they waited and by the draft nothing had been resolved. They took another gamble — trading up for Darrell Taylor. Pre-draft, league insiders had expressed concern about his injury situation. He hadn’t been cleared to perform at the Senior Bowl or combine.
Due to the global pandemic, nobody could do the necessary homework on the injury.
Feeling desperate, the Seahawks traded a third rounder to move up in round two to select Taylor. He didn’t play a down as a rookie and faces an uncertain future.
This time there was no Clowney trade. They started the 2020 season asking Benson Mayowa — usually a rotational lineman — to play a large bulk of the snaps and be their primary pass rusher. More responsibility was placed on Collier and Rasheem Green.
Inevitably, it didn’t work.
By the mid-way point in the season they were on a historic pace in terms of passing yards conceded. They had a 3% sack percentage, the most total yards conceded per game and a horrendous third down conversion rate.
They’d practically doubled their usual blitzing total in order to try and create pressure.
A tremendous strain was being placed on Russell Wilson who was having to carry the team, putting up his own historic numbers in the first six games of the season just to engineer a cluster of tight victories.
The Seahawks were winning but it wouldn’t take much for the piñata to shatter. A 5-0 start was followed by a 3-4 record.
They made a trade for Carlos Dunlap before the deadline. Suddenly, they had a pass rusher. The defense transformed. It wasn’t all down to the performance of Dunlap. He did, however, seem to bring everyone together.
Jarran Reed was back to his best. Mayowa returned to his rotational role which suited him. The extra blitzing was a complement rather than a necessity. Their sack percentage more than doubled — going from 3% to 6.4%.
It’s a stretch to say the defense was a ‘strength’. They beat up a lot of bad opponents and second and third rate quarterbacks. The unit wasn’t a liability any more though — which, based on the way the season started, was a plus.
The Seahawks cut Dunlap recently to save $14m. It’s understandable that they didn’t want to pay him that much. An extension rather than a parting would’ve been preferable. Yet here we are.
They simply cannot afford not to bring him back.
Nobody should deem it acceptable to face a third year in a row of drifting along, hoping a solution emerges down the line to fix the pass rush. That would be rank neglect.
Pointing to the brief flashes from Alton Robinson — who only played 29% of the defensive snaps in 2020 — isn’t enough. He needs to be a bigger part of the rotation, not the person you hang your hat on.
Taylor has to prove he can even practise before we can invest any faith that he’ll play for the Seahawks. Even if he does play this year — how much can you realistically expect from him?
We’ve seen enough of Green and Collier to know that, if we’re being honest, they’re both eminently replaceable.
The Seahawks have been aggressive in many ways over the last few months. They traded the house for Jamal Adams. They just gave the Raiders one of their few remaining draft picks to acquire Gabe Jackson and his $9.35m salary. They traded up for Taylor.
There’s absolutely no reason to muck about with Dunlap and try to save a few pennies.
There’s currently $67m in non-guaranteed salary on the roster that can be moved around to create cap space.
There’s no excuse not to create room and get something done with Dunlap. And then once you’ve got him back on board — you can play the market to bring in a #2. But only then. Not now, not with Dunlap still unsigned.
If he goes somewhere else, what’s the alternative? A 33-year-old Ryan Kerrigan? A 32-year-old Melvin Ingram coming off an injury?
A return for Clowney barely seems realistic given what happened last year and it’s already been reported he’ll take his time (again) as he recovers from a knee injury.
There aren’t any other options after that.
Plus you only have two draft picks in the top-130. If they still owned their #1 pick (#23) they’d be in the perfect spot to tap into the pass rushers in the class. By #56 — the options are much thinner. And you don’t want to force another pick, again, because you failed to act in free agency.
It’s confounding how this same issue has dogged the Seahawks for years. It’s a terrible review of the front office efforts, frankly.
It speaks to the misuse of resources that so much has been ploughed into other positions (linebacker, safety) rather than a key position such as defensive end.
Look at the rest of the division:
— The Rams have Aaron Donald and Leonard Floyd
— The Cardinals have Chandler Jones and JJ Watt
— The 49ers have Nick Bosa, Arik Armstead, Dee Ford and Javon Kinlaw
The Seahawks have Collier, Green, Robinson and Taylor.
You’re not competing for any Super Bowls with that. It’s time to get this sorted — now. No more waiting for the exact right value. If you have to pay a bit more to get Dunlap back — so be it.
And as I’ve suggested all along — if you need to be bold and sacrifice an asset to do it, so be it.
You spent a first round pick on a middle linebacker a year ago. Why do that when you’re already paying your starter $17m this year and $20m next year?
In 2019 you traded down from the first round into the early second to select Marquise Blair. You made that call, nobody forced the Seahawks to select him. Then you trade an obscene amount for a blitzing box safety.
You could trade Jamal Adams and give his $9m salary to Dunlap and get back in the draft to fill other remaining holes and depth.
Whatever way they do it, something needs to be done now before it’s too late.
They have to create resource. At the moment, it’s not clear how they’re going to fill out the roster with no money and three draft picks.
They could of course restructure Russell Wilson’s contract right now without even consulting him. The Chiefs and Patrick Mahomes just did it. They choose not to though, despite the saving it would create. You can only assume they haven’t done this so they can leave their options open regarding a trade. That’s where this franchise is at.
They cannot continue with this annual game of musical chairs with the pass rush, or with the mystery surrounding Wilson’s future.
It’s time a little pressure was applied by people on the outside, so that pressure can be applied by those on the field.
If you missed my interview with Jake & Stacy on 710 ESPN on Friday, talking Seahawks and the draft, check it out below…
You can now support Seahawks Draft Blog via Patreon by clicking the tab below.